How to share your product on Reddit without getting banned
Reddit is where many indie products find their first real users, and where many founders get removed within minutes. The rules are mostly unwritten now, but they are consistent: earn standing first, lead with value, and treat each subreddit as its own country.
Last updated June 17, 2026Reddit bans bad self-promotion, not self-promotion. Stay safe by following the 90/10 rule (at most one in ten of your posts and comments is about your own thing), building account age and karma before you ever promote, reading each subreddit’s own rules, and leading with genuine value. The format that works is honest: I built this, here is what I learned, here are the real numbers, with no hard call to action. Break the ratio or post from a fresh account and you get removed, shadow-banned, or suspended.
- The 90/10 rule is the baseline: roughly 90% genuine participation, 10% or less self-promotion. Many subreddits enforce stricter, closer to 95/5 or 99/1.
- New accounts that promote get caught. Build a few weeks of history and some karma first; a fresh account dropping a product link is the single biggest trigger.
- Each subreddit is its own country. What r/SideProject welcomes will get you permanently banned in r/technology. Always read the sidebar before posting.
- The post that works shares real numbers and real failures and lets people find the product through context, rather than ending on a pitch.
Reddit does not ban self-promotion. It bans bad self-promotion, and it does so fast: a brand-new account dropping a product link in the wrong subreddit can be removed in minutes and shadow-banned without warning. The frustrating part for founders is that Reddit is also one of the best channels a no-audience product has, because a single honest post in the right subreddit can drive more signups in a day than a month of anything else. The whole skill is staying on the right side of one line, and that line is mostly about standing.
01 · The 90/10 realityThe one rule under all the others
The most-cited Reddit self-promotion guideline: roughly 90% of your activity should be genuine participation (comments, discussion, helping people) and no more than 10% should mention your own product or content. Reddit retired the official page years ago, but the expectation lives on through its spam and manipulation policies and through individual subreddit rules, and many communities enforce something stricter.
The number is less important than the disposition behind it. The working test is simple: would your comment still be useful if you deleted every mention of your product? If yes, you are participating. If the comment exists only to drive a click, you are promoting, and ten of those in a row is what gets you removed. Experienced Reddit marketers tend to run closer to 95/5, not because a rule demands it, but because that ratio is what a genuinely helpful member’s history naturally looks like.
So the first move is not a post. It is a few weeks of being useful in the communities where your user gathers, so that when you do share your product you are a familiar contributor, not a stranger with a link.
02 · The age and karma gatesWhy new accounts get caught
The single biggest trigger for removal is the pattern of account created recently, immediately promoting. It lights up every spam filter Reddit has, and many subreddits add their own account-age and karma minimums on top.
There is no universal karma number, because each subreddit sets its own, but the principle holds: your account should not look brand new when you first mention your product. Build a couple of weeks of genuine comments, accumulate enough karma that you read as a real person, and only then share anything of your own. This is unglamorous and it is the difference between a post that sticks and an account that gets quietly burned.
If your posts suddenly get zero engagement everywhere, you may be shadow-banned: invisible to everyone but yourself, with no notification. It is Reddit’s quiet penalty for spam-like behaviour. Check your account in a logged-out browser; if your recent posts do not appear, you are shadowed, and the usual fix is to stop, rebuild genuine history, and appeal to moderators rather than keep posting into the void.
03 · Read the sidebar firstEvery subreddit is its own country
The biggest mistake is treating “Reddit” as one place with one set of rules. It is thousands of communities with wildly different tolerances, and the same post can be welcome in one and a permanent ban in another.
Maker-friendly subreddits exist precisely for this, within their own rules. The variance is the whole point: what r/SideProject welcomes will get you permanently banned somewhere like r/technology, where self-promotion is forbidden. Before you post anywhere, read the sidebar and the pinned rules. Some require a flair, some ban links, some have a dedicated promo thread you must use instead of a standalone post, and some have a self-promotion megathread that is the only sanctioned venue. Ignoring these is how founders get banned while believing they followed the rules.
04 · Value first, no hard CTAThe post that actually works
The format that lands on Reddit is the opposite of a launch announcement. It is a story with real substance, where the product is discoverable through context rather than pushed.
The shape that works: share what you built, what you learned, and real numbers, including the failures, and let people find the product if they want it. “I launched Pagewatch three months ago, here is what worked and what completely flopped” invites discussion; “Check out Pagewatch, the best page monitor” invites removal. Disclose that it is yours, openly. Do not end on a call to action; if the post is good, people will ask for the link in the comments, and a link given on request reads completely differently from a link pushed.
Be a member who happens to have built something, not a marketer who happens to be in the room.
This is also where Reddit’s payoff compounds. A genuinely useful post stays searchable, gets found from Google for months, and increasingly gets pulled into AI answers, so one good thread keeps working long after launch day.
Will a Reddit spike actually convert on your page?
A good Reddit post sends curious, skeptical people to your site. If the page does not immediately say what the product does, they leave. Nilkick checks whether your page is sharp enough to keep them, alongside the rest of your readiness signals.
05 · RecoveryIf you do get removed
Removals happen, sometimes even when you followed the rules, because moderation is human and uneven. If a post is removed, do not repost it elsewhere immediately; that compounds the spam signal. Message the moderators politely, ask what rule you missed, and if you genuinely over-promoted, acknowledge it and show that you have contributed since. Bans are sometimes lifted for accounts that demonstrate a real change in behaviour.
The honest summary: Reddit rewards patience and punishes shortcuts. The founders who get their first users here are the ones who showed up, helped, and earned the right to share, then shared something worth reading. That is slower than a directory blitz and far more effective, which is the recurring lesson across every launch venue: being absent from where your users gather is a Footprint problem, and presence is something you build, not buy.
Common questions
Get your free launch-readiness score
See what else is between your product and its first real users — Nilkick scores your readiness and hands you the map. Free, no login.
https:// optional · no account · we don't email you
Where to launch a product with no audience in 2026
A ranked, honest map of where to launch a product with zero audience in 2026, sorted by what actually sends you humans versus what just builds footprint.
How to introduce your product on Indie Hackers
Indie Hackers is quieter than it was, but still a real place to get builder feedback and durable relationships. How to introduce a new product there, honestly, in 2026.
Launching on Product Hunt with no followers: what actually works
Product Hunt in 2026 rewards early velocity and human curation, so a cold launch with no audience usually sinks. Here is what genuinely moves the needle, and when to skip it.